Welcome to this week's edition of "Who to Start, Who to Sit", where I'll be analyzing the best
and worst plays of the week.
To start off, I'll tell you what quarterbacks I'm high on for week 5.
QuarterbackWho to start:
Peyton Manning (at Houston): This is the week where Peyton Manning puts up his stats of old. He's getting 3 key starting offensive linemen back this week (LT Tony Ugoh, RT Ryan Diem, and C Jeff Saturday) and his knee should feel better with the week off. Look for him to have more time to get the ball downfield to his receivers and put up multiple touchdowns against a soft Houston defense.
Jon Kitna (vs Chicago): Kitna has has a rough beginning to the season. Luckily for him and his Lions teammates, their bye week came in week 4. WR Roy Williams has complained about the lack of spreading the field and how they would start every game with 2-wide and only open things up after their conservative playcalling got them into large deficits. It appears that the coaching staff heard his call, as their offensive coordinator said that they will start to use 3 and 4 wide receiver sets early in the game. This bodes well for Kitna and his 2 star receivers, Williams and Calvin Johnson. Add in that Rudi Johnson ran like it was 2004 in week 3 before the bye, and things are looking up for the so far stagnant offense of the Lions.
Jake Delhomme (vs Kansas City): Jake is showing no ill effects from the Tommy John surgery he underwent last season. Steve Smith has come back and added 166 yards and a TD in 2 game to an offense that was already doing well. Mushin Muhammad looks younger (I guess having Steve Smith on the other side of the field can do that for you) and Delhomme is reaping the benefits. Patrick Surtain and Brandon Flowers will have their hands more than full this week, and they will soon realize that Steve Smith is a lot harder to tackle than Brandon Marshall.
Who to sit:
Carson Palmer (at Dallas): It appears Palmer is set to start on Sunday, but he's going up against one of the more relentless pass rushes in the league. The Bengals offensive line hasn't been able to give Palmer enough time to get the ball downfield and the pressure is forcing him into a lot of mistakes. Chris Henry is back from suspension, but so far it doesn't look like he'll be activated for Sunday's contest. I like Palmer and the Bengals to bounce back in a big way, but it's not likely to happen this week. Elbow soreness and inflamation isn't anything to take lightly, just ask Jake Delhomme, so I'm not really sure why Palmer would play in a game that they're virtually guaranteed to lose. Go with a safer option this week.
Matt Hasselbeck (at New York Giants): Matt Hasselbeck gets his 2 best receivers back this week, but it's still not a good week to play Hasselbeck. Thought there is some scuttlebutt about how explosive Deion Branch looks, the fact is he's coming off of major knee surgery, making it unlikely that they will let him completely loose. The matchup isn't going to be kind to Hass this week. Keep him on the pine for another week.
Jason Campbell (at Philadelphia): Campbell has been great thus far and looks to be grasping Zorn's west coast offense well. He faces a tough Philly defense this week, however, and they have the speed to cover the short routes that Campbell depends on to open up the long ball. Clinton Portis matches up better against the Eagles because he will break plenty of tackles against undersized defensive players. Both of Campbell's TDs came at the goal line last week and that won't happen again if they want to keep Portis happy.
Running BackStart:
Marshawn Lynch (at Arizona): Lynch had a quiet game last week in a good matchup, but he gets to try again against another weak defense. Despite not scoring last week, he's still tied for 2nd most rushing TDs, and he'll score at least one this week.
Steve Slaton (vs. Indianapolis): The Texans have found their running back, at least for now. Indianapolis boasts one of the worst run defenses and until Bob Sanders comes back, which won't be for a while, they will continue to yield large totals to opposing running backs.
Reggie Bush (vs. Minnesota): Minnesota does have a good run defense, but they are vulnerable to guys that can push the ball to the outside, as Chris Johnson was able to do last week against them. Bush's part in the passing game should also play into his hand this week. He should have a nice day.
Sit:
Julius Jones (at New York Giants): Julius Jones has been good thus far, but he faces his first real test this week against a defense that doesn't seem to know they lost their best 2 players. He should do ok, but he won't have stats close to what he's been putting up, as the Seahawks struggle to move the ball on Sunday.
Ryan Grant (vs. Atlanta): I know the matchup is good, but the last great matchup he had, against the Lions, he only rushed for 20 yards(!) on 15 carries(!). He doesn't look as explosive as he did last year.
Rudi Johnson (vs. Chicago): Rudi looked great 2 weeks ago, but he's still going to split carries with Kevin Smith. Chicago's weakness is in the air, not on the ground, so Rudi shouldn't see more than 10 touches.
Wide ReceiverStart:
Muhsin Muhammad (vs. Kansas City): Moose is back! Patrick Surtain will need loads of help covering Steve Smith this sunday, which will leave Moose in consistent man coverage with Brandon Flowers, who won't be enough to keep Muhsin from scoring.
Lee Evans (at Arizona): Laveranues Coles scored 3 TDs against Arizona last week and Jericho Cotchery scored 2. Need I say more?
Bobby Engram (at New York Giants): Engram is Matt Hasselbeck's most reliable receiver right now and unlike Deion Branch, Engram's injury wasn't to his knee. Hasselbeck will look his way often as Seattle will need to throw to stay in this game.
Sit:Randy Moss (at San Francisco): Moss won't be a reliable starting option until the Patriots fix their QB situation. The matchup isn't good, either.
Donald Driver (vs. Atlanta): Driver hasn't been that good this year, and Rodgers is a gametime decision.
Deion Branch (at New York Giants): Branch is back, but they might limit his snaps to give his knee a chance to ease back into 100% throttle. Only play him if you have nobody else.